What this rent vs buy calculator compares
“Is it cheaper to rent or buy?” is the wrong question, because the two options don’t cost money in the same way. A buyer spends a lot up front and builds equity in a home; a renter spends less up front and can invest the difference. A fair comparison asks: after the same number of years, which choice leaves you with more money?
This renting vs buying calculator answers that by tracking both paths month by month:
- If you buy, you pay the down payment and closing costs, then a mortgage plus property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA dues. At the end you sell, pay selling costs, repay the loan and keep the rest.
- If you rent, you invest the money the buyer spent on the down payment and closing costs. Each month you pay rent and renters insurance.
- Each month, whichever option is cheaper that month invests the difference. That makes it a rent vs buy calculator with investment built in, so both sides spend the same amount of money each month.
How to use it
- Start with how long you will stay. This is the single most important input.
- Enter the home price, down payment, rate and term from a real listing and a lender quote.
- Add ownership costs: property tax as a percentage of value (your county’s rate or the listing’s tax bill ÷ price), insurance, maintenance and HOA dues.
- Enter closing and selling costs as percentages. Ask a lender and a real estate agent for local figures.
- Enter the rent for a comparable home, your expected rent increase, and the investment return you could realistically earn.
The result shows which option is ahead after your chosen number of years, by how much, and the year buying first breaks even. Open the year-by-year table to see how the gap changes over time.
How it is calculated
Buyer’s net worth = home value × (1 − selling cost %) − loan balance + buyer’s investments Renter’s net worth = (down payment + closing costs, invested) + monthly savings invested Monthly cost to own = mortgage payment + value × tax % ÷ 12 + insurance ÷ 12 + value × maintenance % ÷ 12 + HOA Monthly cost to rent = rent + renters insurance Investments grow monthly at (1 + annual return)^(1/12) − 1
Home value grows at your growth rate each year, and property tax and maintenance grow with it. Rent rises once a year by your rent increase.
Worked example
A $400,000 home with 20% down at 6.5% for 30 years, 1.1% property tax, $1,800 insurance, 1% maintenance, 3% closing costs, 6% selling costs and 3% yearly home value growth, compared with renting at $2,200 a month (rising 3% a year) plus $20 renters insurance, with a 6% investment return.
- First month: owning costs $2,872.62, renting costs $2,220.
- After 7 years, the renter is ahead by about $20,300.
- After 10 years, the renter is still ahead by about $6,756.
- Buying breaks even in year 12, and after 15 years the buyer is ahead by about $29,093.
So with these assumptions, buying makes sense only if you expect to stay well over a decade.
What moves the answer most
- Time: buying has big one-off costs (closing and selling). The longer you stay, the more time home growth and loan paydown have to cover them.
- Price-to-rent ratio: if homes are expensive relative to rents in your area, renting tends to win; if rents are high relative to prices, buying tends to win.
- Home value growth vs investment return: the buyer’s main asset is the house; the renter’s is the investment portfolio. Whichever grows faster favors that side. The ROI calculator turns past returns into an annual rate you can use here.
- Mortgage rate: higher rates mean more of each early payment is interest rather than equity.
- Rent increases: fast-rising rents favor buying, because a fixed-rate mortgage payment doesn’t rise.
Try a cautious and an optimistic version of your numbers. If the answer is the same in both, you can be fairly confident in it.
Things a calculator cannot weigh
Money is only part of the decision. Owning gives stability, freedom to renovate and protection from rent increases. Renting gives flexibility to move for work or family, no surprise repair bills and less of your wealth tied up in one asset. Treat the result as one input alongside these.
Assumptions and limits
- Taxes are not included: no mortgage interest deduction, no tax on investment gains or on the home sale.
- PMI is not included. If your down payment is under 20%, add an estimate with the mortgage payment calculator.
- Growth rates are constant every year; real markets rise and fall.
- The renter is assumed to actually invest the savings. If the money would be spent instead, buying looks better.
- Utilities are assumed to cost the same either way. If a house would use much more energy than a rental, estimate the difference with the electricity cost calculator.
Frequently asked questions
How do I calculate the cost to rent vs buy?
Add up everything each option costs over the same period, then compare what you own at the end. For buying: down payment, closing costs, mortgage payments, property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA dues, minus the home equity you keep after selling costs. For renting: rent and renters insurance, minus what your down payment and any monthly savings would have earned if invested. This calculator does that month by month.
How do I use a rent vs buy calculator?
Enter the home price and loan details, the ongoing costs of owning, the rent for a comparable home, and how long you expect to stay. Then look at the break-even year. If you plan to stay longer than the break-even point, buying tends to come out ahead under your assumptions; if shorter, renting usually does.
Why does renting often win for short stays?
Buying has large one-off costs: closing costs when you buy and selling costs when you sell. It takes years of home-value growth and loan paydown to earn those back. Over a short stay, the renter’s invested down payment can grow more than the buyer’s equity.
What assumptions matter most?
How long you stay, home price growth, rent increases and investment returns have the biggest effect. Small changes to these can move the break-even year by several years, so try a cautious and an optimistic set of numbers.
Does this include taxes?
No. Results do not include income tax deductions such as mortgage interest, taxes on investment gains or on the sale of a home. Tax rules depend on your situation, so check with a tax professional if they are likely to matter for you.